Gray Cars for sale in Bay Shore, New York
414 cars found
Save this search
Modify Your Search
Location
Price
Hide cars with no price
Under $5,000 (1)
Under $10,000 (12)
Under $15,000 (31)
Under $20,000 (86)
Under $25,000 (145)
Under $30,000 (181)
Under $35,000 (201)
Under $45,000 (230)
Under $55,000 (246)
Under $70,000 (256)
Under $90,000 (267)
Unknown (143)
see all
see less
Mileage
0 miles (15)
Under 10,000 (173)
Under 20,000 (197)
Under 30,000 (235)
Under 40,000 (289)
Under 50,000 (319)
Under 60,000 (342)
Under 70,000 (355)
Under 80,000 (374)
Under 90,000 (385)
Under 100,000 (391)
Over 100,000 (8)
see all
see less
Year
2025 (79)
2024 (40)
2023 (20)
2022 (54)
2021 (68)
2020 (20)
2019 (75)
2018 (21)
2017 (10)
2016 (5)
2015 (6)
2014 (4)
2013 (3)
2012 (6)
2011 (1)
2009 (1)
2006 (1)
see all
see less
Make
see all
see less
Bodystyle
see all
see less
Transmission
Automatic (294)
CVT (41)
Manual (4)
Unknown (75)
Drivetrain
AWD (212)
4WD (4X4) (121)
FWD (70)
RWD (9)
Fuel Type
Gasoline (378)
Gas/Electric Hybrid (12)
Plug-in Hybrid (10)
Flex Fuel (4)
Electric (4)
Bio Diesel (2)
Diesel (2)
see all
see less
Interior Color
Black
(243)
Gray
(66)
Beige
(10)
Brown
(8)
Red
(6)
Maroon
(1)
Silver
(1)
Tan
(1)
White
(1)
?
Unknown
(94)
see all
see less
Only show fuel efficient
Only show cars with photos
Only show cars with C.A.R.Score
Standard Listings
Save this car
$19,989 ($377/mo est.)
Mileage: 43,638
1 photo
Mileage:
43,638
Exterior Color:
Gray
Interior Color:
Diesel Gray / Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
Automatic
$19,989 ($377/mo est.)
Sayville, NY
(1,144 miles from )
(1,144 miles from )
Save this car
$22,885 ($432/mo est.)
Mileage: 79,686
20 photos
Mileage:
79,686
Exterior Color:
Graphite Metallic
Interior Color:
Jet Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$22,885 ($432/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$19,995 ($377/mo est.)
Mileage: 34,446
24 photos
Mileage:
34,446
Exterior Color:
Electric Shadow
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
$19,995 ($377/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$35,655 ($673/mo est.)
Mileage: 94,120
22 photos
Mileage:
94,120
Exterior Color:
Lead Foot
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$35,655 ($673/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$26,995 ($509/mo est.)
Mileage: 32,987
22 photos
Mileage:
32,987
Exterior Color:
Carbonized Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Ebony
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$26,995 ($509/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$22,995 ($434/mo est.)
Mileage: 61,650
21 photos
Mileage:
61,650
Exterior Color:
Magnetic Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Medium Slate
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$22,995 ($434/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$13,750 ($259/mo est.)
Mileage: 53,711
21 photos
Mileage:
53,711
Exterior Color:
Granite Crystal Clearcoat Metallic
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
$13,750 ($259/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$17,255 ($326/mo est.)
Mileage: 54,135
22 photos
Mileage:
54,135
Exterior Color:
Gray
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
CVT
$17,255 ($326/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$24,395 ($460/mo est.)
Mileage: 37,018
21 photos
Mileage:
37,018
Exterior Color:
Lithium Gray
Interior Color:
Ebony
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$24,395 ($460/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$26,355 ($497/mo est.)
Mileage: 81,510
20 photos
Mileage:
81,510
Exterior Color:
Tungsten Metallic
Interior Color:
Jet Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$26,355 ($497/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$26,755 ($505/mo est.)
Mileage: 17,079
22 photos
Mileage:
17,079
Exterior Color:
Iced Mocha
Interior Color:
Sandstone
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$26,755 ($505/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$36,555 ($690/mo est.)
Mileage: 66,741
1 photo
Mileage:
66,741
Exterior Color:
Magnetic Metallic
Interior Color:
Ebony
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$36,555 ($690/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$44,255 ($835/mo est.)
Mileage: 14,915
20 photos
Mileage:
14,915
Exterior Color:
Sterling Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Jet Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$44,255 ($835/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$15,555 ($294/mo est.)
Mileage: 76,531
21 photos
Mileage:
76,531
Exterior Color:
Magnetic Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Ebony
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$15,555 ($294/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$29,775 ($562/mo est.)
Mileage: 82,607
20 photos
Mileage:
82,607
Exterior Color:
Magnetic Metallic
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$29,775 ($562/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$39,705 ($749/mo est.)
Mileage: 26,176
1 photo
Mileage:
26,176
Exterior Color:
Lead Foot
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$39,705 ($749/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$40,495 ($764/mo est.)
Mileage: 27,851
21 photos
Mileage:
27,851
Exterior Color:
Grigio Maratea Metallic
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$40,495 ($764/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$8,495 ($160/mo est.)
Mileage: 167,402
22 photos
Mileage:
167,402
Exterior Color:
Gray
Interior Color:
Charcoal Black
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$8,495 ($160/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$24,695 ($466/mo est.)
Mileage: 36,575
22 photos
Mileage:
36,575
Exterior Color:
Carbonized Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Ebony
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$24,695 ($466/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$10,995 ($207/mo est.)
Mileage: 97,286
21 photos
Mileage:
97,286
Exterior Color:
Mineral Gray Clearcoat Metallic
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$10,995 ($207/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
Contact for Price
Mileage: 117,000
1 photo
Mileage:
117,000
Exterior Color:
Carbon Black Metallic
Interior Color:
Ebony
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
Contact for Price
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$39,500 ($745/mo est.)
Mileage: 36,011
20 photos
Mileage:
36,011
Exterior Color:
Carbonized Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Black W/medium Dark Slate
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$39,500 ($745/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$41,995 ($792/mo est.)
Mileage: 37,581
20 photos
Mileage:
37,581
Exterior Color:
Magnetic Metallic
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$41,995 ($792/mo est.)
Saint James, NY
(1,139 miles from )
(1,139 miles from )
Save this car
$39,247 ($741/mo est.)
Mileage: 31,803
32 photos
Mileage:
31,803
Exterior Color:
Carbonized Gray
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
17/22
$39,247 ($741/mo est.)
Wantagh, NY
(1,122 miles from )
(1,122 miles from )
Save this car
$31,947 ($603/mo est.)
Mileage: 6,411
37 photos
Mileage:
6,411
Exterior Color:
Magnetite Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
CVT
$31,947 ($603/mo est.)
Wantagh, NY
(1,122 miles from )
(1,122 miles from )
This image is a stock photo and is not an exact representation of any vehicle offered for sale. Advertised vehicles of this model may have styling, trim levels, colors and optional equipment that differ from the stock photo.
Close
Filter Results
Updating Results